UNIGE document Scientific Article
previous document  unige:7971  next document
add to browser collection

Effects of item and rater characteristics on checklist recording: what should we look for?

Published in Medical education. 2005, vol. 39, no. 8, p. 852-858
Abstract OBJECTIVE: Examinations based on using standardised patients (SPs) commonly use checklist recordings to evaluate students' clinical performance. This paper examines whether and to what extent item and rater characteristics affect the reliability of history checklist recording in an SP-based assessment. METHODS: Checklist items were reviewed for the presence or absence of 5 item characteristics and a 2-point versus 3-point scoring scale. Agreement between checklist recordings obtained from SPs and clinician-examiners (CEs) were compared by item characteristics, scoring scale and CEs' level of involvement in the assessment. RESULTS: Based on 3179 pairs of recordings, the overall percentage of agreement between SPs and CEs was 83% (kappa = 0.64). Agreement was significantly higher for items scored on a 2-point than on a 3-point scale, and when the CE was also the author and the trainer of the station. After controlling for other factors, item characteristics were only marginally associated with level of interrater agreement. CONCLUSIONS: This study suggests that attention should be paid to specific aspects of checklist development and checklist recording training when an SP or CE is used as recorder.
Keywords Clinical CompetenceEducation, Medical, UndergraduateEducational MeasurementHumansMedical History TakingPhysical ExaminationStudents, MedicalTeaching
PMID: 16048628
Full text
Article (Published version) - document accessible for UNIGE members only Limited access to UNIGE
Article (Accepted version) (204 Kb) - public document Free access
Research group Acquisition de l'expertise médicale (662)
(ISO format)
HUBER, Philippe et al. Effects of item and rater characteristics on checklist recording: what should we look for?. In: Medical education, 2005, vol. 39, n° 8, p. 852-858. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2929.2005.02226.x https://archive-ouverte.unige.ch/unige:7971

481 hits



Deposited on : 2010-06-21

Export document
Format :
Citation style :