Scientific article
OA Policy
English

Generalizability of Standardized Patient-Based and Written Assessments of Clinical Skills

Publication date1989
Abstract

Perlormance-based examinations that use standardized-patient (SP) cases have been used to assess the clinical competence of senior medical students in seven classes (1986- 1992) at Southern Illinois University School of Medicine. Because of the length of the examinations, two or more (multiple) SPs have been used to simulate about half of the cases in each examination. An earlier study found little or no effect of using multiple SPs on the intercase reliability of checklist scores, written scores, and total scores. The present study was conducted to assess the effect of multiple SPs on the intercase reliability of SP ratings of interpersonal and communication skills. Although the ratings were not used to determine total scores or to make pass - fail decisions, it seems reasonable to expeJt that multiple SPs might have a greater impact on ratings on non-cognitive dimensions than on ostensibly more objective checklist and written scores. In general, the results showed that generalizability coefficients free of measurement error due to multiple SPs were larger than those reflecting measurement error due to multiple SPs by an average of about 5 percentage points, suggesting that the use of multiple SP raters on the same case reduced reliability by about 5 percentage points. Compared to earlier findings, the effect of multiple SPs on the reliability of ratings was about 4 or 5 times greater than their effect on checklist, written, or total scores. Nevertheless, the magnitude of the effect on ratings was not excessive.

Affiliation entities Not a UNIGE publication
Citation (ISO format)
VU, Nu Viet, COLLIVER, J. A., MARKWELL, S. J. Generalizability of Standardized Patient-Based and Written Assessments of Clinical Skills. In: Proceedings of the annual Conference on Research in Medical Education, 1989, p. 189–194.
Main files (1)
Article
accessLevelPublic
Identifiers
  • PID : unige:26625
Journal ISSN0892-2543
574views
154downloads

Technical informations

Creation21/12/2012 10:54:00
First validation21/12/2012 10:54:00
Update14/03/2023 20:04:19
Status update14/03/2023 20:04:19
Last indexation30/10/2024 08:55:49
All rights reserved by Archive ouverte UNIGE and the University of GenevaunigeBlack