en
Book chapter
English

Policy evaluation in the legislative cycle

Published inHandbook of Public Policy Evaluation, Editors Frédéric Varone, Steve Jacob, and Pirmin Bundi, p. 64-75
PublisherCheltenham : Edward Elgar
Collection
  • Handbooks of Research on Public Policy
Publication date2023-10-19
Abstract

Integrating both ex-ante and ex-post evaluations in the legislative cycle leads to better lawmaking. Legislations can thus produce a fair and optimal impact based on evidence, contributing to solving societal problems in a relevant, efficient, reflexive and fair way. It should be the role of the courts, namely, to verify that this is the case, which they accomplish mainly through the proportionality test. Furthermore, evaluations help the courts to uphold fundamental rights and principles. In practice, however, the quality of regulatory impact assessments has often reported as being flawed and legislators frequently do not take evaluation results seriously. Moreover, the integration of evaluation into the legislative process has enabled the development of innovative types of legislation such as temporary laws subject to review (sunset and experimental legislation), self-regulatory triggering laws (Damocles laws) or legislation by objectives (programmatic laws). In the future, artificial intelligence applied to legislation could possibly reshape the role of evaluation.

eng
Keywords
  • Better lawmaking
  • Legisprudence
  • Regulatory impact assessments (RIA)
  • Judicial review
  • Proportionality test
  • Policy evaluation
Citation (ISO format)
FLÜCKIGER, Alexandre, POPELIER, Patricia. Policy evaluation in the legislative cycle. In: Handbook of Public Policy Evaluation. Cheltenham : Edward Elgar, 2023. p. 64–75. (Handbooks of Research on Public Policy) doi: 10.4337/9781800884892.00011
Main files (1)
Book chapter (Published version)
accessLevelRestricted
Identifiers
ISBN9781800884892
46views
1downloads

Technical informations

Creation11/17/2023 8:06:47 AM
First validation11/17/2023 8:13:11 AM
Update time11/17/2023 8:13:11 AM
Status update11/17/2023 8:13:11 AM
Last indexation05/06/2024 5:22:43 PM
All rights reserved by Archive ouverte UNIGE and the University of GenevaunigeBlack