Scientific article
OA Policy
English

Two approaches to quality in institutional settings. Comparison of the revision policies of an intergovernmental organisation and the Swiss Confederation

ContributorsRiondel, Aurélienorcid
Published inMikaEL, vol. 14, p. 82-96
Publication date2021
Abstract

This paper addresses translation quality assurance and revision policies in two institutional con-texts: an intergovernmental organisation (Institution A) and the Swiss Confederation (Institution B). It is based on 20 semi-structured interviews with heads of department, translators and revisers. The analysis is organised in two parts. First, the main aspects of the quality assurance models in place are described and categorised based on the models defined by Joanna Drugan (2013). Second, extending Gabriel González Núñez's (2016) translation policy concept to revision, the paper describes and compares the revision policies of the two translation departments and high-lights some advantages and disadvantages of each as put forward by participants. The analysis shows that the organisation of work and the approach to revision is very different in the two institutions. The comparison brings to light significant differences in practice but also notes several beliefs regarding revision shared by both teams. Other findings are that the hierarchical structure in place in Institution A can be burdensome and that discussions organised in Institution B are appreciated overall.

Keywords
  • Revision
  • Institutional translation
  • Interviews
  • Revision policy
Citation (ISO format)
RIONDEL, Aurélien. Two approaches to quality in institutional settings. Comparison of the revision policies of an intergovernmental organisation and the Swiss Confederation. In: MikaEL, 2021, vol. 14, p. 82–96. doi: 10.61200/mikael.129277
Main files (1)
Article (Published version)
accessLevelPublic
Identifiers
Journal ISSN1797-3112
336views
188downloads

Technical informations

Creation21/05/2021 17:04:00
First validation21/05/2021 17:04:00
Update time06/01/2026 13:43:15
Status update06/01/2026 13:43:15
Last indexation06/01/2026 13:47:17
All rights reserved by Archive ouverte UNIGE and the University of GenevaunigeBlack