Scientific article
OA Policy
English

Legislating or rubber-stamping? : assessing parliament's influence on law-making with text reuse

Publication date2020
Abstract

Law-making is a core function of parliaments in democratic systems. Yet we still know little about the extent to which parliaments influence legislation and the reasons why MPs prioritize some bills rather than others. We analyze the degree of bill amendments operated by parliament, by comparing bills before and after parliamentary deliberations with a text reuse approach. We postulate that MPs attempt to overcome the problem of limited processing by prioritizing certain bills over others, and rely on considerations related to institutional rules, attention dynamics and partisan politics. Empirically, we apply zero-inflated beta regressions on a dataset covering about 1,700 bills adopted from 1995 to 2015 in the Swiss Parliament. Moreover, we consider the government's anticipation strategy to address the problem of observational equivalence affecting analyses of parliament's impact on law-making. Results highlight a reasonably high amendment activity, but with strong variations across bills. MPs change bills more if they are subject to direct democracy, rank high on the parliamentary agenda or if they attract media attention. The influence of the electoral cycle and coalition politics is not confirmed.

Keywords
  • Law-making
  • Parliament
  • Amendments
  • Text reuse
  • Switzerland
Citation (ISO format)
GAVA, Roy, JAQUET, Julien Matthieu, SCIARINI, Pascal. Legislating or rubber-stamping? : assessing parliament’s influence on law-making with text reuse. In: European Journal of Political Research, 2020. doi: 10.1111/1475-6765.12395
Main files (1)
Article (Accepted version)
accessLevelPublic
Identifiers
Additional URL for this publicationhttp://doi.wiley.com/10.1111/1475-6765.12395
Journal ISSN0304-4130
449views
111downloads

Technical informations

Creation27/04/2020 08:39:00
First validation27/04/2020 08:39:00
Update13/10/2025 17:24:55
Status update17/01/2025 16:35:36
Last indexation02/03/2026 12:44:40
All rights reserved by Archive ouverte UNIGE and the University of GenevaunigeBlack