Book chapter
English

Rationing by clinical judgment

Published in

Danis, M., Hurst, S.A., Fleck, L.M., Forde, R. & Slowther, A. (Ed.), Fair resource allocation and rationing at the bedside

Publisher

Oxford : Oxford University Press

Publication date

2014

Abstract

While rationing by clinical judgment is controversial, its acceptability partly depends on how it is practiced. Here, the authors consider rationing by clinical judgment in three different circumstances that represent increasingly wider circles of resource pools in which the rationing decision takes place: triage during acute shortage, comparison to other potential patients in a context of limited but not immediately strained resources, and determination of whether expected benefit of an intervention is deemed sufficient to warrant its cost by reference to published population-based thresholds. Building on notions of procedural justice, an analytical framework that includes six minimal requisites is applied in order to facilitate fair bedside rationing: (1) a closed system that offers reciprocity, (2) attention to general concerns of justice, (3) respect for individual variations, (4) application of a consistent process, (5) explicitness, and (6) review of decisions. The process could be monitored for its applicability and appropriateness.

Keywords

  • Rationing
  • Clinical judgment
  • Triage
  • Constrained resources
  • Procedural justice
  • Reciprocity
  • Variation
  • Explicitness
  • Review

Note

Part Four : Strategies for promoting fair bedside rationing

UNIGE research groups

Citation (ISO format)

HURST, Samia, MAURON, Danis. Rationing by clinical judgment. In: Fair resource allocation and rationing at the bedside. Danis, M., Hurst, S.A., Fleck, L.M., Forde, R. & Slowther, A. (Ed.). Oxford : Oxford University Press, 2014. doi: 10.1093/acprof:oso/9780199989447.001.0001

Identifiers

ISBN

978-0-19-998944-7
519views
0downloads

Technical informations

Creation

27/06/2016 08:42:00

First validation

27/06/2016 08:42:00

Update

15/03/2023 00:29:14

Status update

15/03/2023 00:29:14

Last indexation

31/10/2024 03:45:58
All rights reserved by Archive ouverte UNIGE and the University of Geneva
OpenAIRE Indexed & Validated