• Home
  1. Home
  2. Dekanting preimplantation genetic diagnosis and the saviour child: a personal memoir
Professional article
English

Dekanting preimplantation genetic diagnosis and the saviour child: a personal memoir

Contributors

Mauron, Alex

Published in

Bioethica Forum, vol. 1, no. 2, p. 105-107

Publication date

2008

Abstract

Being both an academic bioethicist and a member of a na-tional ethics body (in my case, the Swiss Bioethics Advisory Commission – NEK-CNE – from 2001 to 2007) is not always easy. The rules of the academic world favour independent thinking, speculative boldness, and examining all arguments with an open eye no matter how preposterous or politically incorrect they may appear at first sight. In «public bioethics» however, possible discourses are heavily constrained by extra-neous considerations. For one thing, the state of current law and the limits of realistic changes carry much weight. As the saying goes, la politique est l'art du possible, and what counts as possible in politics bears little relation to what counts as plausible, or at least worth discussing, in the philosophy seminar. More troublingly perhaps, arguments that cut no ice with many philosophers, or at least are considered mas-sively controversial, are sometimes treated as sacred mantras in public bioethics. Such is the concept of «human dignity». Someone only needs to assert, in the appropriately dour tone, that a particular biomedical practice is «against human dig-nity», and anyone disagreeing is facing an uphill battle.

UNIGE affiliation entities

UNIGE research groups

Citation (ISO format)

MAURON, Alex. Dekanting preimplantation genetic diagnosis and the saviour child: a personal memoir. In: Bioethica Forum, 2008, vol. 1, n° 2, p. 105–107.

Main files (1)

Article (Published version)

Identifiers

  • PID : unige:84256

Additional URL for this publication

http://www.bioethica-forum.ch/docs/08_2/2_08_S105-107_Focus.pdf

Journal ISSN

1662-6001
475views
0downloads

Technical informations

Creation

30/05/2016 12:20:00

First validation

30/05/2016 12:20:00

Update

15/03/2023 00:25:23

Status update

15/03/2023 00:25:23

Last indexation

31/10/2024 03:35:22
All rights reserved by Archive ouverte UNIGE and the University of Geneva
OpenAIRE Indexed & Validated