Psychosis progresses along a continuum. While heterogeneity is evident across the continuum, it remains unknown whether this is also reflected in white matter (WM) heterogeneity and whether parsing WM heterogeneity may reveal subgroups with more pronounced clinical features. This analysis included 212 participants consisting of healthy controls (HC, n = 59), individuals with high schizotypy (SPT, n = 27), at-risk mental state (ARMS, n = 35), and patients with first episode psychosis (FEP, n = 50) and schizophrenia (SZ, n = 41). Fractional anisotropy (FA) and mean diffusivity (MD) were derived from diffusion tensor imaging (DTI), and fibre density (FD), a non-tensor-derived diffusion marker, was computed. The Person-Based-Similarity Index (PBSI) and Coefficient of Variation Ratio (CVR) were computed to assess global and local heterogeneity. ANOVAs were performed to determine whether people with deviating PBSIs exhibit more pronounced clinical features. Global heterogeneity for all diffusion parameters significantly differed across groups, with greatest difference in heterogeneity between SZ and HC. Results further indicate that FA deviators exhibit lower global functioning and higher negative symptoms. Local FA heterogeneity was greater in FEP relative to ARMS and HC in almost all WM tracts, while SZ patients specifically showed greater heterogeneity in the right thalamic radiation and the left uncinate compared to HCs. Group differences in WM heterogeneity might be indicative of symptom specificity and duration. While these findings offer valuable insights into the neurobiological variability of psychosis, they are primarily hypothesis-generating. Future large-scale studies are warranted to test the robustness of diffusion markers and their clinical relevance.