Scientific article
OA Policy
English

Borderline personality disorder and moral responsibility

Published inMedicine, health care and philosophy, vol. 28, no. 1, p. 3-16
Publication date2025-03
First online date2025-01-04
Abstract

This paper seeks to determine the extent to which individuals with borderline personality disorders can be held morally responsible for a particular subset of their actions: disproportionate anger, aggressions and displays of temper. The rationale for focusing on these aspects lies in their widespread acknowledgment in the literature and their plausible primary association with blame directed at BPD patients. BPD individuals are indeed typically perceived as "difficult patients" (Sulzer 2015:82; Bodner et al. 2011), significantly more so than schizophrenic or depressive patients (Markam 2003). The "responsibility question" for patients with BPD has already been raised (Martin 2010; Zachar and Potter 2009; Bray 2003), but this paper tackles it from a novel perspective. First, I narrow down the category of things for which the responsibility question is specific to individual with BPD. After that, I argue that some of the diagnosis criteria of BPD such as emotional instability or impulsivity might serve as excusing factors targeting the "control condition" on moral responsibility. Second, this paper also considers another widely accepted condition on moral responsibility: the epistemic condition. The view defended in the paper is that the answer to the responsibility question for individuals with BPD, concerning both the control condition and the epistemic condition, hinges on an understanding of their epistemic profile.

Keywords
  • Aggressions in borderline personality disorders
  • Borderline personality disorder
  • Control condition on moral responsibility
  • Epistemic condition on moral responsibility
Citation (ISO format)
BAEHNI, Agnes Sophia Constance. Borderline personality disorder and moral responsibility. In: Medicine, health care and philosophy, 2025, vol. 28, n° 1, p. 3–16. doi: 10.1007/s11019-024-10243-6
Main files (1)
Article (Published version)
Identifiers
Journal ISSN1386-7423
1views
0downloads

Technical informations

Creation22/05/2026 08:14:50
First validation02/06/2026 14:57:40
Update02/06/2026 14:57:40
Status update02/06/2026 14:57:40
Last indexation02/06/2026 14:57:41
All rights reserved by Archive ouverte UNIGE and the University of GenevaunigeBlack