Doctoral thesis
English

The temporality of childhood in transitional justice processes aimed at addressing the legacy of past coercive child policies in Switzerland and England

ContributorsPatrizi, Elena
DirectorsHanson, Karl
Number of pages349
Imprimatur date2025-06-12
Defense date2025-03-28
Abstract

Reparation processes related to historical violations of children’s rights are becoming increasingly widespread internationally. In Switzerland and England, such violations have been the focus of reparation processes related to coercive foster placements and compulsory child migration programmes. However, even though these processes have been studied in fields such as law, political science and international relations, there is still a lack of analysis that explores which temporal representation of childhood prevails in discourses of reparation and to what extent such processes can be counted among transitional justice practices. This research aims to fill this gap by examining the main instruments that have characterised reparation processes, including official apologies, research commissions, inquiries, financial compensations and memorials. First, the research investigates which temporality of childhood emerges between ‘been’, ‘being’ and ‘becoming child’ in the discourses of the authorities involved in the reparation process. Secondly, it assesses whether such processes can be considered transitional justice procedures. By means of an analysis based on the literature of childhood studies, children’s rights studies and sources such as official reports, parliamentary debates and transcripts of hearings, the research demonstrates that reparation processes are based on a view of the child rooted in its past and future dimensions. It also highlights how the dimension of the ‘been’ child informs children’s understanding of themselves and contributes to a better appreciation of children and childhood. Analysing the processes in light of the literature on restorative and transitional justice, the thesis concludes that they represent a concrete form of transitional justice in democratic contexts.

Citation (ISO format)
PATRIZI, Elena. The temporality of childhood in transitional justice processes aimed at addressing the legacy of past coercive child policies in Switzerland and England. Thèse, 2025. doi: 10.13097/archive-ouverte/unige:185883
Main files (1)
Thesis
accessLevelRestricted
Secondary files (1)
Imprimatur
accessLevelPublic
Identifiers
255views
21downloads

Technical informations

Creation16/06/2025 21:09:25
First validation27/06/2025 08:42:40
Update06/02/2026 16:50:04
Status update06/02/2026 16:50:04
Last indexation06/02/2026 16:50:05
All rights reserved by Archive ouverte UNIGE and the University of GenevaunigeBlack