Book chapter
English

An iconography of pity and a rhetoric of compassion : War and humanitarian crises in the prism of American and French newsmagazines (1967-1995)

ContributorsGorin, Valérieorcid
PublisherBristol : Intellect
Collection
  • European Communication Research and Education Association series
Publication date2013
Abstract

This chapter explores the rhetoric of compassion in media framings of humanitarian crises in a historical and cultural perspective across space and time. lt shows the first results of an exploratory analysis of media narratives and images of war between the 1960s and the 1990s. Benefiting from the cover of the mass media, modern humanitarianism has played a controversial role in raising public opinion and influencing politics and has contributed to the appearance of the 'victim' concept and its representation in the media throughout the twentieth century, along with images of pain and dea th. 'Victimization', or the tendency to induce a hierarchy among victims, offers an immediate reading of such humanitarian crises according to a simplified and Manichean scheme. But since media representations insist on producing figures of innocent suffering su ch as women and children, their narratives and images often fall back on older collective references and memories. Using 'framing mechanisms' as methodological tools, these results provide representations that favor Christian iconography and historical parallels such as World War II. These representations act às means of qualifying the crises and result ultimately in the moral condemnation of them. While there are clear distinctions in how conflicts are treated wh en they emerge in western as opposed to Third World countries, on how the ethnie victims' background is presented, and on how the paradigm of distance and proximity is dealt with, these media framings are all aimed at relieving suffering, are based on universally shared values, but are at the same time at risk of resorting to reductive schemes.

Citation (ISO format)
GORIN, Valérie. An iconography of pity and a rhetoric of compassion : War and humanitarian crises in the prism of American and French newsmagazines (1967-1995). In: Selling War : the Role of the Mass Media in Hostile Conflicts from World War I to the ‘War on Terror’. Seethaler, J. (Ed.). Bristol : Intellect, 2013. p. 136–156. (European Communication Research and Education Association series)
Main files (1)
Book chapter (Published version)
accessLevelPrivate
Identifiers
  • PID : unige:184489
Additional URL for this publicationhttps://www.intellectbooks.com/selling-war
ISBN978-1-841-50610-4
23views
0downloads

Technical informations

Creation04/04/2025 12:55:33
First validation14/04/2025 08:32:39
Update14/04/2025 08:32:39
Status update14/04/2025 08:32:39
Last indexation14/04/2025 08:32:39
All rights reserved by Archive ouverte UNIGE and the University of GenevaunigeBlack