Scientific article
OA Policy
English

Spare or transform? Agency frames in transition intermediaries

Published inJournal of cleaner production, vol. 469, 143076
Publication date2024-09
First online date2024-07-16
Abstract

Climate emergency is widely acknowledged. However, our institutions are struggling to find new intervention types to accelerate the transition. This paper analyses this struggle by combining agency theories and discursive approaches to study transition intermediaries, i.e, organizations seeking to foster the transition activities of others. The internal meaning structures of intermediaries are described as interlocking shared action frames, i.e., beliefs and meanings underpinning their activities. These frames are characterized through the definition of pairs of contrasting frame elements along eleven framing dimensions. This conceptualization allows for a semi-quantitative mapping of internal structures. The method is developed and illustrated with the in-depth case study of a Swiss regional utility department running an energy efficiency programme. Analysing a series of exploratory workshops, we find that established frames revolve around technology-oriented, managerial approaches to the transition, ultimately narrowing the range of imaginable interventions. While these are well-studied shortcomings of energy efficiency centred approaches, further observations suggest that these frames underpin the perception of intervention impacts, helping keep staff and recipients involved. To strike a balance between energy saving targets and transformative ambitions, this paper suggests revising programme evaluation logics and reframing technological solutions as responses, rather than substitutes, to practice changes.

Keywords
  • Regime-based transition intermediary
  • Agency of intermediaries
  • Internal meaning structures
  • Shared agency frames
  • Strong structuration
  • Energy efficiency programme
Research groups
Citation (ISO format)
MENDES DE MATOS GUIBENTIF, Thomas Vasco, PATEL, Martin Kumar. Spare or transform? Agency frames in transition intermediaries. In: Journal of cleaner production, 2024, vol. 469, p. 143076. doi: 10.1016/j.jclepro.2024.143076
Main files (1)
Article (Published version)
Identifiers
ISSN of the journal0959-6526
13views
2downloads

Technical informations

Creation17/07/2024 10:08:52
First validation02/09/2024 10:04:16
Update time02/09/2024 10:04:16
Status update02/09/2024 10:04:16
Last indexation07/10/2024 00:10:26
All rights reserved by Archive ouverte UNIGE and the University of GenevaunigeBlack