Scientific article
Review
OA Policy
English

Immunogenicity and safety of routine vaccines in children and adolescents with rheumatic diseases on immunosuppressive treatment — a systematic review

Published inEuropean journal of pediatrics, vol. 181, no. 4, p. 1329-1362
Publication date2021-12-22
First online date2021-12-22
Abstract

The immunogenicity of vaccines in children with juvenile autoimmune rheumatic diseases (JARDs) can be reduced, there are additional safety concerns around vaccination, and there is a potential for worsening in disease activity. In this systematic review, we summarise studies that investigated the immunogenicity and safety of routine vaccines in children and adolescents with JARD on immunosuppressive treatment. We identified 37 studies investigating 2571 children and adolescents with JARD on immunosuppressive treatment and 4895 control children. Of the 56 geometric mean antibody titres measured, 19 (34%) were lower, six (11%) higher, and 31 (55%) similar; of the 39 seroprotection rates measured, 10 (26%) were lower, two (5%) higher, and 27 (69%) similar; and of the 27 seroconversion rates measured, nine (33%) were lower, two (8%) higher, and 16 (59%) similar in children with JARD on immunosuppressive treatment compared with control children. However, many of the studies were underpowered, and not designed to show non-inferiority between children with JARD and controls. Subgroup analysis for different types of immunosuppressive treatments was not feasible, as most studies did not report results by treatment. Severe adverse events were reported in 38 children (33 with juvenile idiopathic arthritis, four with systemic lupus erythematosus, and one in a healthy child); most of them were likely not related to the vaccination (e.g. elective hospitalisation or surgery). A worsening in disease activity was reported in 44 (2%) children with JARD; again, many of them were likely not related to the vaccination. There were no safety concerns with live attenuated vaccines; however, only few studies reported results for this.

Conclusion : Vaccination in children with JARD on immunosuppressive treatment is safe and should be promoted, especially since these children are at increased risk for infection. The importance for the completion of vaccination schedules should be stressed. Strategies to compensate for the lower vaccine responses, which are found in approximately one-third of these children, include measuring antibody levels to determine the optimal timing for the administration of additional booster doses.

What is Known: • Children with juvenile autoimmune rheumatic diseases (JARDs) are at higher risk for infections, due to their underlying disease and their immunosuppressive treatment. • In children with JARD, the immunogenicity of vaccines might be reduced, and concerns about safety or the potential for worsening in disease activity after vaccination exist. What is New: • Our systematic review shows that vaccines in children with JARDs on immunosuppressive treatment are safe and immunogenic. • There are several limitations of the currently published studies, including random timing of measuring vaccine responses and age differences between children with JARD and control groups. Many of the studies were underpowered, and not designed to show non-inferiority between children with JARD and controls.

Keywords
  • Antibodies
  • DMARD
  • Disease activity
  • Humoral response
  • Immunisation
  • Juvenile arthritis
  • Juvenile autoimmune rheumatic diseases
  • Juvenile dermatomyositis
  • Systemic lupus erythematosus
Citation (ISO format)
KELLER, Michèle, PITTET, Laure, ZIMMERMANN, Petra. Immunogenicity and safety of routine vaccines in children and adolescents with rheumatic diseases on immunosuppressive treatment — a systematic review. In: European journal of pediatrics, 2021, vol. 181, n° 4, p. 1329–1362. doi: 10.1007/s00431-021-04283-w
Main files (1)
Article (Published version)
Identifiers
Additional URL for this publicationhttps://link.springer.com/10.1007/s00431-021-04283-w
Journal ISSN0340-6199
61views
32downloads

Technical informations

Creation01/12/2023 09:09:42
First validation04/12/2023 09:42:48
Update time04/12/2023 09:42:48
Status update04/12/2023 09:42:48
Last indexation01/11/2024 06:56:58
All rights reserved by Archive ouverte UNIGE and the University of GenevaunigeBlack