Scientific article
English

Replicability in Lithic Analysis

Published in

American antiquity, p. 1-24

Publication date

2023-04-12

First online date

2023-04-12

Abstract

The ubiquity and durability of lithic artifacts inform archaeologists about important dimensions of human behavioral variability. Despite their importance, lithic artifacts can be problematic to study because lithic analysts differ widely in their theoretical approaches and the data they collect. The extent to which differences in lithic data relate to prehistoric behavioral variability or differences between archaeologists today remains incompletely known. We address this issue with the most extensive lithic replicability study yet, involving 11 analysts, 100 unmodified flakes, and 38 ratio, discrete, and nominal attributes. We use mixture models to show strong inter-analyst replicability scores on several attributes, making them well suited to comparative lithic analyses. Based on our results, we highlight 17 attributes that we consider reliable for compiling datasets collected by different individuals for comparative studies. Demonstrating this replicability is a crucial first step in tackling more general problems of data comparability in lithic analysis and lithic analyst's ability to conduct large-scale meta-analyses.

Keywords

  • Stone tools
  • Inter-analyst replicability
  • Attribute analysis

Citation (ISO format)

PARGETER, Justin et al. Replicability in Lithic Analysis. In: American antiquity, 2023, p. 1–24. doi: 10.1017/aaq.2023.4

Main files (1)

Article (Published version)

Identifiers

Journal ISSN

0002-7316
73views
0downloads

Technical informations

Creation

13/04/2023 09:43:14

First validation

18/04/2023 11:40:11

Update

18/04/2023 11:40:11

Status update

18/04/2023 11:40:11

Last indexation

01/11/2024 04:49:25
All rights reserved by Archive ouverte UNIGE and the University of Geneva
OpenAIRE Indexed & Validated