Overeating typically follows periods of energy deficit, but it is also sustained by highly palatable foods, even without metabolic demand. Dopamine D1 receptor-expressing medium spiny neurons (D1-MSNs) of the nucleus accumbens shell (NAcSh) project to the lateral hypothalamus (LH) to authorize feeding when inhibited. Whether plasticity at these synapses can affect food intake is unknown. Here, ex vivo electrophysiology recordings reveal that D1-MSN-to-LH inhibitory transmission is depressed in circumstances in which overeating is promoted. Endocannabinoid signaling is identified as the induction mechanism, since inhibitory plasticity and concomitant overeating were blocked or induced by CB1R antagonism or agonism, respectively. D1-MSN-to-LH projectors were largely non-overlapping with D1-MSNs targeting ventral pallidum or ventral midbrain, providing an anatomical basis for distinct circuit plasticity mechanisms. Our study reveals a critical role for plasticity at D1-MSN-to-LH synapses in adaptive feeding control, which may underlie persistent overeating of unhealthy foods, a major risk factor for developing obesity.