Generalist and specialist roles of policy actors: Insights from preferences on AI regulation

Article Article scientifique Article Generalist and specialist roles of policy actors: Insights from preferences on AI regulation eng 2026-01-28 author Trein Josef Philipp 0000-0001-6217-6675 938405 author Lemke Nicole 945124 author Varone Frédéric 0000-0002-5620-3291 636949 Service enseignement, recherche, administratif et technique (SdS) (SCSPS) 09520767251411201 10.1177/09520767251411201 0952-0767 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/09520767251411201 <p>This article examines how the roles of policy actors shape preferences for the regulation of artificial intelligence (AI). We distinguish between generalists, active across multiple policy sectors, and specialists, whose engagement is concentrated mostly in a single sector. We expect that generalists tend to support horizontal, cross-sectoral AI regulation, whereas specialists favor sector-specific, vertical approaches. Our analysis draws on original elite survey data comprising over 190 respondents from France, Germany, and Switzerland, including organizations and individuals engaged in AI governance across banking, health, and social welfare subsystems, as well as actors in the emerging AI policy sector. Using Bayesian regression models, we find indicative evidence that generalist actors—such as public interest groups, or trade unions—are more likely to endorse encompassing regulation, while specialists—such as occupational interest groups or public administrations—are more inclined toward sectoral regulation. This divergence becomes particularly pronounced when actors evaluate whether their own policy field should be integrated into a broader AI regulatory framework: policy fields that have many specialist actors, such as health policy, show markedly lower support for such integration. These findings contribute to public governance scholarship by clarifying how institutional roles influence regulatory preferences in the context of complex, cross-cutting policy challenges. The study contributes to our understanding of actor roles in policy subsystems and cross-sectoral policymaking as well as to Digital Era Governance in the public sector.</p> Dewey 320 121 Département de science politique et relations internationales T3 false Public policy and administration 7e7f53c5-4703-48e2-9bf0-341a18148baf Article (Published version) Public trein-et-al-2026-generalist-and-spe.pdf 881619 application/pdf 060004f7de87ab5a2b2053db671453aefe83564e70254971174124253d48e5d6 openAccess Faculté des sciences de la société / Département de science politique et relations internationales

Title	Published in	Access level	OA Policy	Year	Views	Downloads

Generalist and specialist roles of policy actors: Insights from preferences on AI regulation	Public policy and administration			2026	16	206

Archive ouverte UNIGE

Lemke, Nicole