Constitutional patriotism as a form of citizenship for the European Union

Diplôme Thèse Constitutional patriotism as a form of citizenship for the European Union - recognizing minorities eng 2017-03-08 author Zenovic Predrag 811074 director Gianni Matteo 0000-0001-7584-9525 24599 10.13097/archive-ouverte/unige:95385 urn:nbn:ch:unige-953855 SdS 67 Contemporary political theory is focused on the question of common life of groups and individuals with divergent axiological worldviews. The need for common life, social cohesion and solidarity is sometimes in contradiction to the space of freedom that these groups and individuals require by their very nature. Recognition stands in the nexus of this contradiction: we need rules that will accept us as equal citizens of a polity but at the same time allow for the expression of our difference. Political liberalism informs us with idea that constitutional rules have to be legitimate for those to whom these are directed. What do these two streams of normative reasoning tell us about existing and desirable constitutional orders of polities, specifically postnational like the European Union, and what form of citizenship would account for minorities? I argue that liberal multiculturalism is to some extent just another reinterpretation of the national state which legitimizes the intrusion of the concepts of the good in the sphere not only in politics but in the constitutional outset of modern national states. National majority has always come with various other forms of exclusion: patriarchal, white, heteronormative etc. Thus, with the main discourse of national states that stays at the pedestal of modern European intellectual history we have different kinds and types of minorities, phenomenologically distinctive, but all united by the constitutional and political exclusion they experience within a setting of a national state. Degrees and forms change both historically and geographically but the matrix of exclusion in its essence remains the same: citizenship is used a strategy for social closure that gives majority more of something, be it resources or status. If this is the nucleus of the normative problem that lies in the heart of constitutionalism, democracy and citizenship what is the theoretical solution of this conundrum? In this thesis argue that constitutional patriotism is an optimal form of citizenship for an emerging European polity. This notion is thoroughly analyzed and developed through a new theoretical paradigm. The main idea is that European belonging is based on the allegiance to a certain set of constitutional rights that stem from quasi-constitutional acts and practices of the EU and allow for better recognition of those who I named identity minorities. To be legally equal and recognized, in my understanding, means is to have the same point of reference, the basic set of rules that govern us and give equal standing for our different conceptions of good life. In other words, my thesis, in its philosophical core, is a story about the good and right and their mutual interdependence. Though liberals are often criticized for their insistence on rights, forgetting that rights themselves can be a form of particular good, I try to show that it is still the only normatively acceptable form of establishing an order in which minimal common rights will enable us to have the liberty to establish and achieve our conceptions of the good life. In other words, primacy of rights over good is the only logical solution for the axiological clash that might emerge between these two analytical categories. This conclusion stems from both lines of reasoning applied in my dissertation: theories of recognition and political liberalism. In final chapters I show that EU citizenship is being created in a deterritorialized and postnational polity. These two features give a distinct identity to the EU polity making it more open and inclusive for minorities and I explicate this through three normative arguments why constitutional patriotism is normatively the most acceptable form of EU citizenship. EU citizenship Constitutional patriotism Constitutionalism Constitutional identity Recognition Minorities Dewey 300 10 Faculté des sciences de la société T false 2a5c8570-59ee-4ecc-a8ff-33d06004681e Thesis Restricted Zenovic thesis.pdf 2542023 application/pdf Private 2017-08-08 73c728e86cf1164c01c4cb6159f3a109922d649b908b50f72c4dbf0c9391ecaf restrictedAccess Faculté des sciences de la société

Title	Published in	Access level	OA Policy	Year	Views	Downloads

Constitutional patriotism as a form of citizenship for the European Union - recognizing minorities				2017	839	2

Archive ouverte UNIGE

Zenovic, Predrag