Chapitre d'actes
previous document  unige:5382  next document
add to browser collection

La logique peut-elle mouvoir l'esprit ?

Published in Séminaire d'épistémologie comparative. Aix en Provence - 1997 - . 1998, p. 35-53
Collection Dialogue; 37(1)
Abstract This paper attempts to take a new look at the famous Lewis Carroll paradox about Achilles and the Tortoise. It examines in particular the connections between Lewis Carroll's regress argument for logical inferences and a similar regress for practical inferences. The Tortoise's point of view is espoused: no norm of reasoning or of conduct can in itself "make the mind move," only the brute force of belief can. This conclusion is a Humean one. But it does not imply that we renounce altogether the normative force of such principles of reasoning as <I>modus ponens<D>. Connexions with the Wittgensteinian rule-following problem are indicated.
Keywords EpistemologyParadoxRuleCarroll, LewisWittgenstein
Full text
Proceedings chapter (257 Kb) - public document Free access
(ISO format)
ENGEL, Pascal. La logique peut-elle mouvoir l'esprit ?. In: Séminaire d'épistémologie comparative. Aix en Provence. [s.l.] : [s.n.], 1998. p. 35-53. (Dialogue; 37(1)

168 hits



Deposited on : 2010-03-09

Export document
Format :
Citation style :