Scientific article

When Is a Country Multinational? Problems with Statistical and Subjective Approaches*

ContributorsStojanovic, Nenadorcid
Published inRatio Juris, vol. 24, no. 3, p. 267-283
Publication date2011

Many authors have argued that we should make a clear conceptual distinction between mononational and multinational states. Yet the number of empirical examples they refer to is rather limited. France or Germany are usually seen as mononational, whereas Belgium, Canada, Spain and the UK are considered multinational. How should we classify other cases? Here we can distinguish between (at least) two approaches in the literature: statistical (i.e., whether significant national minorities live within a larger state and, especially, whether they claim self-government) and subjective (i.e., when citizens feel allegiance to sub-state national identities). Neither of them, however, helps us to resolve the problem. Is Italy multinational (because it contains a German-speaking minority)? Is Germany really mononational (in spite of the official recognition of the Danes and the Sorbs in some Länder)? On the other hand, is Switzerland the “most multinational country” (Kymlicka)? Let us assume that there is no definite answer to this dilemma and that it is all a matter of degree. There are probably few (if any) clearly mononational states and few (if any) clearly multinational states. Should we abandon this distinction in favour of other concepts like “plurinationalism” (Keating), “nations-within-nations” (Miller), “postnational state” (Abizadeh, Habermas), or “post-sovereign state” (MacCormick)? The article discusses these issues and, in conclusion, addresses the problem of stability and shared identity “plural” societies.

Affiliation Not a UNIGE publication
Citation (ISO format)
STOJANOVIC, Nenad. When Is a Country Multinational? Problems with Statistical and Subjective Approaches*. In: Ratio Juris, 2011, vol. 24, n° 3, p. 267–283. doi: 10.1111/j.1467-9337.2011.00484.x
Main files (1)
Article (Published version)
ISSN of the journal0952-1917

Technical informations

Creation08/30/2019 12:15:00 AM
First validation08/30/2019 12:15:00 AM
Update time03/15/2023 6:50:26 PM
Status update03/15/2023 6:50:26 PM
Last indexation05/05/2024 4:25:55 PM
All rights reserved by Archive ouverte UNIGE and the University of GenevaunigeBlack